Dalglish Out After Tumultuous Season

The willing savior plays scapegoat and we should all be thankful.

By Sam Mathius 

Stark numbers, disheartening statistics, and anemic attacking form marked Liverpool’s season. The end of the season was a welcome one, even given the capture of the Carling Cup. Perhaps no one was more relieved to see the campaign end than Kenny Dalglish himself.Now his second spell as Liverpool manager is over as well. The writing has been on the wall since the sacking of Damien Comolli as the club’s Director of Football in April. In the wake of that development, Dalglish did the admirable thing even if it didn’t do him any favors: he didn’t distance himself from Comolli’s record of subpar signings for the club. With Jose Enrique providing the exception, the likes of Stewart Downing, Jordan Henderson, and Charlie Adam headlined a group of new players that failed to find their feet in the squad. Downing never got going (0 goals and 0 assists in the league) and only looked confident and willing to take on defenders down the wing in a handful of games. Henderson was often an absent bystander on the field, trying to find some way to influence the game as he was shuffled between the right flank and central midfield. Adam displayed some of the more suspect tackling ability in Europe this season.

It seems harsh to axe Dalglish in the wake of an unprecedented class of flops but he ultimately had to take the brunt of the blame. Some of the Scots tactical decisions were suspect. It was never going to be easy to fill the Lucas sized gap in the midfield; however, a reckless Charlie Adam was not the answer. It took several weeks for Dalglish to put faith in a young Jay Spearing who lacked Adam’s passing ability but was a much more assured presence to buffer attacks from the back line. That’s even considering the wee man’s many rush of blood to the head moments.

The management of Downing and Henderson were equally bewildering at times. Alternate options were spurned in favor of keeping out of form players in the lineup. The experience and clever play of Maxi Rodriguez was often left on the bench while an expensive Downing made the same uncreative runs and passes down the left side of the pitch. A confident Jonjo Shelvey was recalled from a promising loan spell at Blackpool after Lucas’ injury, only to sit on the bench as Henderson did little to warrant the number of starts he made. Token appearances at the end of the season showcased a Shelvey that looked sapped of confidence and unable to make simple passes. Dirk Kuyt was another player who seemed to be shunned in favor of Henderson, despite the young Englishman looking confused and lost on the flank.

It’s far from being a singular an explanation for a poor season and is a harsh assessment of Dalglish’s managerial ability. There were a number of factors that made this year a difficult one for the manager and club. The Luis Suarez racism scandal was a delicate situation that provided an endless distraction for the club. An attack labeled as being toothless was simply unlucky at times. With 488 shots taken, only one club (Chelsea – 489) took more shots in the league this year.  According to BleacherReport, Liverpool hit the post or missed penalties on twelve occasions in the league up to the March 3rd loss to Arsenal. Had each strike gone in, it would have resulted in an additional eight points for the Reds. Even so, factoring that in, a Champions League spot wouldn’t have been in the cards. Still, that loss to Arsenal was demoralizing. In that game alone, a penalty was missed and the post was struck twice. What could have been a 4-2 win for Liverpool, who played the better football on the day, was a heartbreaking loss that effectively ruled us out of the race for fourth. Of the twelve league matches after that game, the Reds lost seven including low-lights against relegation candidates Wigan and QPR.

With the continual increase of quality competition in the EPL, it’s difficult for all managers to meet and exceed expectations, particularly when luck hasn’t been on your side. Had the attacking ability of the club been augmented by a bit more confidence, depth, and luck the season would have turned out much differently. After all, Liverpool’s defensive record was the third best in England, just after Manchester City and Manchester United.

Kenny Dalglish will always be King. His reputation hasn’t been tarnished as many fear. The last several years have been difficult for the club on the field and this season wasn’t going to be any different. Don’t forget that Dalglish was very much the club’s savior after Roy Hodgson’s departure. He pumped life, confidence, and excitement for the next season into the team and fanbase.

Even so, some things can’t be ignored, particularly his tactical approach. Too often it was stale and uninventive despite stagnant play that was cagey and negative. The desire to take a chance and mix things up was ironically absent from a club led by a man who reached legendary status for his creative attacking skill.

Perhaps we’ve asked and expected too much from a man who has already given everything to the club. A slow process of rebuilding in the wake of those former owners who shall not be named started with the appointment of our King. He was the only one that we could rely on. He was the only one we could ask to make the sacrifice. Keep in mind, he was never labeled as a long-term solution, more so a bridge through a difficult period that realistically wouldn’t bear fruit for the club. He placed his excellent record and hero status on the line to take a chance on a club that was lacking in many departments.

An eighth-place finish seems like a failure after a summer of heavy spending. However, placing this last year in the context of Liverpool Football Club’s recent history, fans may look back on this year as being one of the bet managerial jobs ever done. It would be a travesty to think less of a man’s reputation for leading us to two cup finals, humbly playing the scapegoat in the Suarez-Evra saga, and most importantly never dropping his head while serving the club with grace and pride. Instead of diminishing his illustrious record with Liverpool Football Club, Kenny Dalglish has only enhanced his standing with his second spell as manager. In many ways, he’s brought us through the fire.  For that he deserves our best wishes and total respect. The King he will forever be.

Now it’s time to move on. The names that have been knocked around to fill the managerial position include Andre Villas-Boas, Roberto Martiniez, and Rafa Benitez.

Let us know what you think about Kenny’s departure and whom you want to see in charge. Comment below.


6 thoughts on “Dalglish Out After Tumultuous Season

  1. A very well written post about how our King took us far from troubled times and steadied the ship. True that luck was not always on our side and he got the tactics and team horribly wrong at times, but a piece of silverware is a right step in a positive direction. The defeat to Arsenal was the most demoralizing of all the defeats and that started the horror run of dropping points and losing towards the end of the season. I’m glad the season is now over and I hope for a big name manager like Villas Boas to arrive, especially since our current principles of young talent is in line with what he was trying to achieve at Chelsea. With no disrespect, I feel we should move past Martinez, he may have achieved good things at Wigan but ours is a huge club and with that comes immense pressure. And I don’t think he’ll be a good manager at Liverpool, especially after seeing someone like Roy Hodgson falter at Liverpool. More and more I think Villas Boas would be the best option and with some smart spending over the summer, I think we can build a great team. I would say we are in need of four players, one at the central back to cover for injuries and Carragher is getting old; one good defensive central midfielder to cover for Lucas (clearly Adam is not the man for tackling, Spearing and Shelvey are inconsistent and without experience), an attacking creative midfielder to support Gerrard, someone who can link the midfield with the forwards, and an extra forward to add depth to Suarez and Carroll and can put the ball in the net time and time again. Suarez and Carroll were beginning to link up well towards the end of the season which is a good sign. Only if we had an Ozil or Mata (like Gerrard) who can spread the ball to the wings to let crosses flying in for Carroll to attack, I believe we can build a title challenging team in the coming season. Raheem Sterling is an exciting talent that should be nurtured and used well, he could very well become a top player for Liverpool.
    It’s time to move on now, and King forever he shall be, Dalglish deserves our praise and best wishes. Thank you King Kenny.


  2. Scapegoat is the correct word to use. I’ve been a supporter of LFC for over 40 years and have experienced the good the bad and the extremely ugly. Seeing Kenny sacked in such an unpleasant way leaves a sour and painful taste. Towards the end of his first ‘full’ season it was (imo) obvious to see that the team in general were really beginning to really gel and (again mo) Downing was the biggest disappointment. Downing though has been chosen for the English team? one of four Liverpool players plus Henderson in the squad. It was obvious to me and many supporters that next season under Kenny we would see these new players fully gel and with added players we would be a real force. This season saw us play some amazing attacking football with bad luck and contentious decisions deciding the negative outcomes. Though it’ll be the dire play in ‘lesser’ games being most remembered by many.

    So now, Kenny sacked and who will replace him? There is not one English manager worthy to replace Kenny, though many names have been bandied around the press. I would laugh if I didn’t feel so bad! Kenny deserved another season or at the very least till Christmas………

    As for the Suarez/Evra affair…………Kenny was left high and dry to deal with accusations, a media storm I’ve never experienced and the sad fact is…………………………had any journalist worth his salt actually read through all the FA’s findings and reported the discrepancies therein it would never have the saga it became.

    The new manager, god help him, has to make 4th place to be successful. If that doesn’t happen what next? another manager? We are becoming Chelsea without the Chelsea funds.

    If it’s the Champions League that our esteemed owners require there is only one manager available and that is Rafa Benitez. Other ‘top’ European managers would and should avoid us like the plague, we have become a poisoned chalice!


    • Thanks for the response Jeanette,

      100% agree that Kenny was pretty much left to deal with the Suarez-Evra saga all on his own. The only player, coach, or upper management lad that said something was Glen Johnson after the handshake and it didn’t get much coverage. That has to take a toll on someone for sure.

      As for our next manager, I think Stan Collymore’s tweet yesterday says it all:

      “Would a top class manager go to Liverpool.. Form is temporary,class is permanent.One of a handful of global big boys.Thats the truth.”

      Very interesting time to appoint a manager. Seems to be a lot of positives to the plethora of candidates out there.



      • Oh Lordy, Martinez in talks??? Make of that what you will. He’s just sooooooooooooo good cos he saved Wigan from relegation twice? Cheap option methinks


        • “Would a top class manager go to Liverpool.. Form is temporary,class is permanent.One of a handful of global big boys.Thats the truth.”

          Well Mr Mathias…..appears none of the ‘global big boys’ got a look in or not interested? Latest news from the BBC

          Roberto Martinez ‘offered’ Liverpool job

          This is according to the Wigan owner! PLEASE let this not be true…………..


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s